Washington auctioned Pacific seabed leases despite a court ruling against its environmental review
Washington auctioned Pacific seabed leases despite a court ruling against its environmental review
The United States has auctioned seabed leases near American Samoa, pressing ahead with a first-of-its-kind mining sale even as a federal court faulted the environmental review behind it. The dispute turns on what the leases permit now—and whether the government can open a path to mining without properly weighing the risks first.
The auction covered two areas totaling about 31.5 million acres and brought in $6 million, according to reports. Wetstone US Ventures won both leases; accounts differ on whether it was the only bidder, with one report naming Adepth Minerals as an auction participant. The leases allow preliminary work such as mapping, not immediate mining. Federal officials cast the sale as a step toward mineral security, citing materials used in clean-energy technologies, electronics and defense. They say any later development would face U.S. safety and environmental standards.
Opponents see the legal sequence differently. A Hawaii federal judge found that the National Marine Fisheries Service failed to consider potential effects on protected species under the Endangered Species Act. The Guardian’s account describes the environmental clearance as voided and reports that Earthjustice called the auction unlawful; a conservative outlet stresses that the judge did not vacate the lease sale itself. That distinction leaves the auction’s immediate status contested, even as the ruling undermines the review used to justify it.
For Pacific critics, the concern extends beyond the courtroom: they say communities closest to the ocean were sidelined while the seabed was treated as a commercial asset. “The Pacific is not for sale,” Guam Senator William Parkinson said, warning that Washington should not sell first and ask whether it was legal later. Supporters, by contrast, argue that mineral supplies are strategic and that early-stage exploration could help secure them. The leases therefore mark more than a technical auction: they set a precedent for whether resource-security claims can move ahead of unresolved environmental and consultation disputes, with further proposed sales near Guam and the Northern Mariana Islands also facing legal challenges.
Write a comment