Trump’s Times lawsuit advances, but two claims are thrown out
Trump’s Times lawsuit advances, but two claims are thrown out
A federal judge has kept the central claims in Donald Trump’s $15 billion defamation lawsuit against The New York Times and Penguin Random House alive, while dismissing two others. The split ruling gives Trump a procedural victory—but leaves the case far from a decision on whether the publishers defamed him.
Judge Steven Merryday said Trump had plausibly alleged that the 2024 book Lucky Loser portrayed him as planning and carrying out complex crimes without adequate support. The conservative account emphasized Merryday’s view that the authors should have sought an expert opinion on whether the facts supported that implication. He called failing to obtain one “a fine example of the purposeful avoidance of the truth.” The claims concerning two Times articles, by contrast, were dismissed.
The liberal account stressed the limited reach of the decision: the judge was assessing whether the complaint contained enough facts to proceed, not weighing evidence at trial. It also noted that an earlier, longer complaint was rejected for its presentation, and that the amended filing narrowed the case. The Times has previously called the lawsuit “obviously meritless,” while Penguin Random House has said it stands by the book and its authors.
The accounts converge on the key point: Trump’s claims over the book survive for now, but the lawsuit has not been proven. They differ in emphasis. The conservative report frames the ruling as a major boost for Trump and highlights the potential scrutiny of reporting standards; the liberal report places it in the context of Trump’s broader legal campaign against media companies and underscores the claims the judge dismissed.
The case invokes the demanding “actual malice” standard for public officials, requiring proof that defendants knew a statement was false or recklessly disregarded its truth. Discovery and further court rulings will determine whether any surviving claims reach a jury.
Write a comment