He sold bitcoin to buy bitcoin. It made sense.
- Marcus, in his words
- What he did, in numbers
- How it worked on Bitcoin Well
- Why it works
- The rule that doesn’t apply (yet)
- Is this you?
In late October, with bitcoin about $30,000 below where it sat a year earlier, a customer we’ll call Marcus sold part of the bitcoin on his hardware wallet at a loss. He took the loss on his taxes, used the cash to open two IRAs, and bought bitcoin back inside them. Most people fund a Bitcoin Well IRA with an old 401(k) or cash from the bank, so here’s how selling bitcoin to buy bitcoin left Marcus with a better tax position and his stack in two places instead of one.
This is a composite story built from real customer conversations. Names and numbers are changed. The rules are real. It isn’t tax advice. Please talk to a tax professional about your own situation.
Marcus, in his words
Marcus is 44, single, and his job has no retirement plan. He’s held bitcoin on a hardware wallet since 2021. Some of it he bought last fall at around $110,000. That part was underwater.
Why sell coins you held yourself?
“I had two problems. Coins sitting at a loss, and I’d never opened an IRA. Selling the losing coins paid for fixing the second one.”
Why not just buy them back in your wallet?
“Then I’ve just pushed the tax bill down the road. Inside a Roth, the growth is never taxed if I follow the rules. Inside a Traditional, I got a deduction this year. And I can still see the bitcoin on-chain. It’s real.”
You kept most of your stack in self-custody.
“Yes. The Binance hack happened the same week, and it reminded me that everything fails somehow. Exchanges get hacked. Hardware wallets get lost, or you get phished. A custodian with insurance is a different risk, not zero risk. I’d rather split it than bet everything on one.”
What he did, in numbers
Illustrative and rounded. We used $75,000 as the sale price, close to where bitcoin traded in late October and early November.
One detail made this work. Before selling, he wrote down exactly which coins he was selling: the ones bought last fall, by date and price paid. If you don’t identify them, the IRS assumes you sold your oldest coins first. For Marcus, those were his cheap 2021 coins, and the sale would have been a gain, not a loss.
How it worked on Bitcoin Well
Marcus did all of it in one place. He sold his bitcoin for cash on the Bitcoin Well Portal, used that cash to fund his two IRAs, and bought bitcoin inside each one. The whole process took less than an hour.
Why it works
The loss. A loss only counts once you sell. It first cancels out any other gains you have this year. Whatever’s left, up to $3,000 comes off your regular income, and the rest rolls into future years. Marcus had no other gains, so $3,000 of his $5,250 loss comes off his 2026 income and $2,250 carries forward.
The IRAs. You can put $7,500 into IRAs for 2026 ($8,600 if you’re 50 or older), and you have until April 15, 2027 to do it. It has to go in as dollars, not bitcoin, which is why Marcus had to sell first. Roth money grows tax-free: no tax on the gains when you take it out in retirement, as long as you follow the rules. Roth contributions have an income limit (for single filers in 2026 it phases out between $153,000 and $168,000). Traditional money is a tax deduction today: every dollar you put in comes off the income you pay tax on this year. Marcus put in $3,000, so that’s another $3,000 off his 2026 taxable income on top of the $3,000 from the loss. He gets the full deduction because he has no retirement plan at work. If you do have one, income limits apply. Which mix is right for you is a question for a tax professional.
The custody. On October 29, hackers took about $6.3 billion from Binance, the biggest theft the industry has seen. Binance says it has covered customer losses, and Marcus wasn’t a customer anyway. But the week made the point we wrote about in Every Bitcoin Bear Market Ends With an Exchange Blowing Up: exchanges fail one way, hardware wallets fail another, and a qualified custodian fails a third way. Inside his IRA, his bitcoin is held by BitGo as qualified custodian, titled to his IRA, and verifiable on-chain from his dashboard. BitGo carries a $250 million insurance policy on the assets it holds. Outside the IRA, he still holds his own keys. No single bad day takes everything. (Adam laid out where the IRA sits on that spectrum in The Counterparty Ladder.)
He skipped the ETF route. A fund tracks bitcoin. He wanted bitcoin.
The rule that doesn’t apply (yet)
Stocks have a “wash sale” rule: sell at a loss and buy back within 30 days, and the loss doesn’t count. Bitcoin held directly is property, not a security, so that rule doesn’t apply to it today. That’s why Marcus could book the loss and buy back the same week. (Bitcoin ETF shares are securities, so if you hold bitcoin through a fund, the rule already applies to you.)
That could change. Congress has floated extending the wash sale rule to digital assets more than once, and nothing has passed. If it ever does, the IRA part of this move is the piece to watch: for stocks, the IRS has ruled (Revenue Ruling 2008-5) that buying the same stock back inside your own IRA within 30 days is a wash sale, and the loss is gone for good. That doesn’t touch bitcoin today. It’s the reason to check the current rules with a tax professional before you sell, not after.
Is this you?
Bought bitcoin in the past year? Hold it yourself? Never opened an IRA?
Then you have the same three pieces Marcus had: coins at a loss, unused 2026 IRA room, and a stack sitting in one place.
We can’t tell you whether to sell or how to split Roth and Traditional. A tax professional can. We can explain how the account works, what the limits are, how the custody is set up, and how to verify your bitcoin on-chain. If you already hold bitcoin and want to know how it could fit into an IRA, reach out.
Flat annual fee. No setup fee. No fee to leave. The usual trading spread applies; see the fees page.
Open your Bitcoin Well IRA at bitcoinwell.com, or email hello@bitcoinwell.com.
Originally published at bitcoinwell.com/blog
Write a comment