Two mathematicians claim the Riemann Hypothesis—and the human-versus-AI stakes are rising

Levent Alpöge says Claude helped him prove the Riemann Hypothesis; Stanford researcher Alessandro Masullo says he has a separate, AI-free proof. Neither claim has been independently verified.
Two mathematicians claim the Riemann Hypothesis—and the human-versus-AI stakes are rising

Two mathematicians claim the Riemann Hypothesis—and the human-versus-AI stakes are rising
Levent Alpöge, a mathematician on Anthropic’s technical staff, said Friday that he had used the company’s Claude AI to solve the Riemann Hypothesis, a 167-year-old problem about the distribution of prime numbers. He described Claude as having begun to “leave me in awe,” but the proposed proof is extraordinarily long: Alpöge said it runs to more than 250,000 pages. Cornell mathematician Steven Strogatz called the problem mathematics’ “Moby Dick,” while cautioning that the proof had not been independently verified.

Alpöge said he had reached the result on Sunday, then held off announcing it while he consulted mathematicians. A computer-based system had checked the work, Strogatz said, but such systems can make mistakes. UCLA mathematician Terence Tao also warned that assessing the argument would take time. The claim, if it holds, would resolve a Millennium Prize Problem carrying a $1 million award.

Hours after Alpöge’s announcement, Stanford postdoctoral researcher Alessandro Masullo published a separate proof, saying he had worked on the problem for 12 years—and had been about a year from releasing his results before the news changed the timetable. He acknowledged that the version was rushed and could contain errors. Unlike Alpöge, Masullo said his work did not use AI, and framed its release as a reminder to mathematicians unsettled by the pace of AI advances: “we are still here.”

The two submissions now face the same test: scrutiny by mathematicians. Neither had been formally proven by Friday afternoon, and Masullo’s shorter paper immediately sharpened the debate over whether AI is transforming mathematical discovery or simply adding another claim to verify. Strogatz summed up the sudden turn in the contest: “The plot thickens!”

https://foxvector.com

Write a comment