AI and a human both claim the Riemann prize—and neither proof is settled
AI and a human both claim the Riemann prize—and neither proof is settled
On Friday, Anthropic mathematician Levent Alpöge said he had completed a proof of the Riemann hypothesis with help from Claude, the company’s AI system. Instead of a conventional paper, he posted a four-page note and linked to code he said could verify the result. “Claude flew, and danced, and sparkled near that finish line,” Alpöge wrote. The claim concerns a problem that has resisted proof for more than 160 years and carries a $1 million Millennium Prize.
The announcement drew excitement as well as caveats. Cornell mathematician Steven Strogatz called the hypothesis “the Mount Olympus” of mathematics, while saying Alpöge appeared to have played a key role guiding Claude’s explorations. Google CEO Sundar Pichai joined the celebratory reaction, posting: “Somewhere Euler, Gauss and Riemann in awe today!”
Hours after Alpöge’s announcement, Stanford postdoctoral researcher Alessandro Masullo said he, too, had solved the problem—without AI. He said he had worked on it for 12 years and was close to releasing his results when Alpöge’s claim prompted him to publish an unfinished version. Masullo warned it might contain errors, but framed his announcement as a defense of human mathematicians: “We are still here. We are very much alive. We are not going anywhere.”
By Friday afternoon, neither proof had been formally established, and mathematicians were scrutinizing both. The contrast is sharp: Alpöge’s account presents AI as a powerful collaborator, while Masullo’s emphasizes human persistence—and the risk that a rushed race to publish can leave errors behind. Elon Musk, meanwhile, celebrated the potential breakthrough while acknowledging uncertainty: “Even if Riemann turns out not to be fully solved yet, it will be soon enough.”
Write a comment