El's Chronicles: Shadow Island // Chapter 7
Chapter 7
The sun filtered weakly through the thin kitchen curtains. When I drew them open, pale golden light poured in, filling the room with the fragile warmth of early March.
In the quiet of the morning, I found solace in my little ritual. As the water bubbled through the coffee maker, the smell of fresh coffee spilled into the room, cutting through the lingering chill. I poured it into a sturdy mug and wrapped both hands around the heat.
Despite the screams coming from the woods, I’d slept surprisingly well once I knew what was making them. I felt rested and considerably more cheerful, though still a little embarrassed about waking Zan over the local fox population’s sex life. Reading up on foxes seemed like the right thing to do.
Zan walked into the kitchen, rubbing the back of his neck. His hair was tousled, his shirt creased from sleep. “Morning,” he mumbled, heading straight for the coffee maker to pour himself a cup.
“Morning,” I replied, thumb still scrolling through an article about foxes. I watched him for a second, then said, “Did you know a group of foxes is called a skulk?”
His eyes lifted to mine over the rim of the mug. “Yes.”
I nodded, as if I’d expected that.
“Hey,” he said. “You weren’t imagining the house noises.”
“What do you mean?”
“The knocking,” he explained, setting his mug on the counter. “Last night, I heard it too. Like someone was outside, or inside, rapping on the windows.”
A wave of vindication swept over me, mingled with a fresh thread of unease. “You’re sure?”
He nodded, crossing his arms. “Positive. And I think I know where it’s coming from.”
Together, we started inspecting the windows, moving from room to room. In the living room, Zan stopped beside one of the larger frames.
“Wait.”
A gust rattled the window, followed by a few taps. He pressed his hand against the narrow strip of wood running along the inside of the frame.
“Here. Listen.”
He tapped the strip with a knuckle, then tried its edge with his thumbnail. One end lifted slightly.
“It’s loose,” he said.
I moved closer as he took a multitool from his pocket and worked the blade beneath the wood. With a little pressure, the strip came away from two small nails, revealing a narrow recess carved into the frame.
A tarnished key hung from a nail inside it.
Zan nudged it with his fingertip. It swung against the side of the recess, making the same faint knocking sound.
“There’s our visitor,” he said. “Every time the window shakes.”
He lifted the key off the nail. It was small, delicate, and engraved with the initials E.H.
“Elias Harrington?” I whispered, my voice barely audible over the pounding of my heart.
Zan’s expression darkened as he turned the key over in his hands. Something behind his eyes recalibrated as the air between us tightened.
I leaned closer, trying to catch a glimpse of the key as if seeing it from another angle might make it confess its purpose. “What do you think it opens?” I asked, my voice breaking the silence that had settled like dust.
“I don’t know, El. I haven’t seen it before.” His eyes stayed on the metal, his thumb tracing the initials as though he could decipher them by touch alone.
My curiosity twisted into impatience. “A desk drawer? Maybe a jewelry box? Come on, you’re the local historian here, help me out.” I laughed under my breath, half from nerves, half from irritation. “You’re killing me, Zan. Please don’t go mute on me…” He glanced up, a look that stopped me mid-sentence faster than words ever could.
“It’s nothing,” he said at last, the words clipped clean, like he wanted them gone as soon as they left his mouth. He turned the key over once more, the metal glinting in the light, then closed his fist around it. “Harrington’s been dead a long time.” His voice was almost too steady, each word carefully controlled. “Let it rest. Whatever it opens doesn’t matter anymore.”
He placed the key beside him, as if to end the conversation there, but his eyes stayed on it for a second too long. Then he looked away.
I had already searched every inch of the house and was certain that whatever this key opened, it wasn’t here.
I skimmed through the chaos of Archivum documents scattered across every surface, piled on the floor like relics of my own obsession, trying to make sense of everything I’d learned from them in light of this key.
I looked up at Zan, the question slipping out faster than I meant it to. “Whatever happened to Harrington’s boat?” I asked, watching his face.
His eyes were fixed on the key. “Let it go,” he said. “It’s been seventeen years. Whatever could’ve been found was found.”
The firmness in his tone wasn’t cruel, but it was final, like a door closing softly between us.
I studied him for a moment, trying to read what sat behind that composure. For him, it was a chapter long finished. For me, it was a beginning that wouldn’t stop pulling at the edges of my mind. Seventeen years for you, I thought. For me, it started last week.
I made my way across the room. The coffee was still hot. I poured two fresh cups, letting the tension burn itself out between us. When I set his mug down beside him, he didn’t look up.
“So,” I said, pausing to take a sip, “are you planning to tell Betty that you found a key with her husband’s initials in this house and decided seventeen years was enough reason to ignore it?” My tone was deceptively casual.
“You were planning on telling her, right?” I said, softer now. His eyes lifted then, and the look he gave me made it clear I was pushing my luck.
“Because I don’t know how your conscience works,” I continued, “but I won’t be able to withhold this from her.”
“Withhold what from her, El? That we found a key? I’m not putting her through this again unless there’s something to tell.” The faint tightening around his mouth told me I’d hit a nerve.
“So let me ask you this,” I said, turning the mug between my hands. “If it doesn’t matter, if you’re so sure it opens nothing, what difference does it make if I look into it? You lose nothing, right?”
“You’re assuming this ends when you’ve satisfied your curiosity. I happen to like things the way they are.”
“You might be right. It might lead nowhere. But I’d rather find that out than keep wondering, and you don’t have to be part of it.” I stepped closer, reached for the key, and dragged it toward me in a single motion. The metal scraped against the wood as I closed my hand around it.
“Would you be kind enough to give me a ride to town?” I said, slipping the key into the pocket of my hoodie.
His head lifted slightly, one brow tilting in calm disbelief. “What for?”
“To ask around,” I said. “See if anyone remembers what happened to Harrington’s boat. Maybe someone’s seen it. Maybe it’s still here. I’ll start with the marina.”
He pressed his lips together, and I had the distinct impression he was holding back a reply I wouldn’t like. For the first time since I’d met him, I could tell I’d gotten under his skin.
“It’s in a private boathouse on the far side of the island,” he said slowly.
“You guys kept the boat?” I asked, certain I must have misunderstood.
He nodded. “It’s the same one they found drifting after Connor and Sierra…” he hesitated, as if choosing his words carefully, “…went missing.”
“The same boat?” I asked, leaning forward.
“Yes,” he said. “For a while, law enforcement held onto it as part of the investigation. When it was released, Betty kept it. At first because we all thought the case might move forward and the boat could still be needed as evidence. Then the years went by, and it just stayed. Harrington used it regularly for his research. He loved that boat. Betty didn’t want to sell it after his death,” he said, his eyes on me. “These days, it stays docked.”
“Can we go check it out?”
He exhaled, rubbing a hand over his jaw. “It’s not that simple. It’s locked. Asking means waiting. And waiting means an audience.”
I raised an eyebrow. “Meaning?”
He gave me a pointed look. “Meaning whoever unlocks the boathouse sticks around to lock it back up. Empty boathouse, one curious local, ears wide open.” He shrugged. “And give it an hour? Half the island will know we were there.”
I rolled the key between my fingers. “So? It’s your boat. What’s the problem?”
He paused, and something in his expression closed. “There’s more attached to this than you understand,” he said, unable to hide his frustration. “I’m not getting into it right now. But I’m not asking anyone to open that door and start people talking. If we go, we go quietly.”
I kept my eyes on him as I considered his answer. It explained almost nothing, which was clearly the point. Still, it was better than no answer at all. “Fine,” I said. “Quietly.”
He nodded once. “No big production. Just a quick look to see if the key opens anything on the boat. If it doesn’t, we leave. No harm done.”
“Okay, but if the boathouse is locked and we just show up on our own… how do we get in?”
Zan didn’t answer right away. He leaned back, rolling his shoulders slightly, as if considering how much to say. “There’s an old service hatch on the side of the boathouse.”
I frowned. “A service hatch?”
“They used it for lines and gear before the dock was rebuilt,” he said. “Most people forget it’s there. I don’t think it’s been sealed.”
Realization clicked into place. I sighed and nodded. “Fine. Let’s go. But if this ends with me explaining myself to the local police, I’m holding you personally responsible.”
He smiled slightly as he stood. “There are no local police. But yeah, let’s make sure we don’t get caught.”
We took Zan’s boat along the coast but docked at a small service pier a short walk from the old boathouse. From there, we went on foot, keeping to the narrow path that cut between the rocks and the wind-bent brush.
By the time we reached the boathouse, it was late afternoon.
Zan led me around the side of the building, where the boards had gone silver with age and salt. Near the back, half-hidden behind a stack of old lobster traps, was a low wooden hatch set into the wall. The hatch groaned when he pulled it open, but it gave way. A minute later, we were inside.
The Odyssey sat near the far end, tied neatly at its berth, its weathered hull catching the soft glow of the afternoon sun creeping into the boathouse.
“This is it,” Zan said, nodding toward the boat. “Stay quiet.”
“Quiet is my middle name,” I whispered dramatically, though my foot immediately caught on a loose plank, sending me stumbling forward. Zan grabbed my arm, steadying me, his expression hovering somewhere between amusement and exasperation.
“Uh-huh,” he murmured, letting go once I was steady. “Are you sure you’ve done this before?”
“Absolutely,” I said with faux confidence. “I’ve seen all the spy movies. How hard can it be?”
Getting to the Odyssey involved a fair bit of sneaking, crouching, and, on my part, whispered commentary about how I was clearly meant for a life of espionage.
“Okay, here’s the plan,” Zan said as we stepped carefully onto the dock. “We’ll check the cabin first. If the key fits, great. If not, we’ll move on to the storage compartments. Should be straightforward.”
The boat rocked gently beneath us as we climbed aboard, the scent of brine and aged wood heavy in the air. The dim light filtering through the small windows painted the interior in muted shades of gray and brown, revealing a space both well-used and eerily undisturbed.
“Let’s start with the obvious,” he said, crouching by a set of drawers near the helm. I nodded, my heart thudding in my chest as I began inspecting the small cupboards along the cabin wall.
We worked in silence, the only sounds the creak of the boat and the occasional clink of metal as Zan opened compartments, rifling through their contents. Each attempt ended the same way. Nothing was locked, and nothing seemed to require the key.
“Anything?” he asked, glancing over his shoulder.
“Nothing,” I muttered, frustration creeping into my voice.
Zan straightened, brushing dust off his hands as he moved toward the navigation area. “If there’s a lock, it’ll be somewhere important,” he said, scanning the panels and dials with narrowed eyes.
I turned my attention to the base of the helm, running my fingers over the worn wood. A faint line in the corner caught my eye, just enough to suggest a compartment. It was covered in grime, the edges nearly invisible against the backdrop of the console.
“Wait,” I said, leaning closer. “Do you think this could be a lock?”
Zan knelt beside me. His fingers brushed the edge of the compartment, clearing away the accumulated dirt until a small keyhole emerged. The metal slid into the lock with a satisfying click, and the compartment creaked open.
Inside was a folded piece of parchment, its edges brittle and yellowed with age. Zan carefully pulled it out, and it revealed a series of handwritten digits, the ink faded but still legible.
Before I could react, a creak echoed from outside the cabin. My breath hitched as a beam of light swept across the windows. It was a flashlight, moving methodically. Someone was here.
Zan froze, his hand on my arm.
“Zan,” I whispered. “What do we do?”
“Hide,” he whispered.
He looked around the cabin, his eyes landing on a small closet at the far end. Without another word, he led me toward it and opened the door, revealing a cramped space filled with neatly hung wetsuits, coiled ropes, and a scattering of diving gear including scuba tanks, fins, and masks. He grabbed my wrist, and in one fluid motion, he stepped inside, turned toward the door, and drew me in with my back against his chest.
The door clicked shut, plunging us into suffocating darkness. His hand moved to my waist, steadying me as the boat swayed beneath us. “Stay still,” he whispered, his breath warm against my ear.
The closet was impossibly small, the air thick with the faint scent of salt and rubber from the wetsuits hanging beside us. My heart hammered in my chest, each beat louder than the creak of the floorboards outside. His arm settled around me, while the other braced against the doorframe.
The warmth of his touch sent a jolt through me, a mix of adrenaline and something far more distracting. I tried to focus on the footsteps outside, the beam of a flashlight sweeping past the cracks in the door, but all I could feel was the intimacy of being held against him.
The footsteps paused, the flashlight lingering just outside the closet. I froze, barely daring to breathe. Zan’s hold on me tightened, his fingers brushing against my ribs.
Finally, the footsteps moved away, the flashlight beam disappearing into the distance. We stayed still a moment longer, the quiet filled only by the measured sound of his breathing.
When the silence stretched too long, I whispered, “Are they gone?”
“Yeah,” he murmured. He released me slowly and opened the door. “You okay?” he asked quietly. I nodded.
We stepped out of the cramped closet, the air outside feeling cooler and strangely thin. My legs were unsteady, the adrenaline still rushing through me, leaving my hands trembling.
“Who do you think that was?”
“Could’ve been anyone,” he said, his expression dark. “But whoever it was, they weren’t supposed to be here.”
I looked at him, then at the pocket of his jacket where the folded parchment was tucked away. “Can I see the paper again?” I asked quietly. “What do you think those numbers are?”
For a long moment, he didn’t move. His eyes held mine as if deciding whether to trust me with what came next. Then, without a word, he reached into his jacket, pulled out the parchment, and unfolded it slowly.
He examined the two broken strings of numbers, divided by a slash. “They look like coordinates,” he said, frowning as he held the paper closer to the dim light. “And it’s not far from here. Maybe six or seven miles.”
I watched him for a few seconds, trying to work out what he was thinking, but his expression gave me little to go on. I had a feeling he was about to find a way to leave me out of this, and although I hoped I was wrong, I turned back to the parchment and began committing the numbers to memory.
I glanced left, then up, then down, mentally tagging the digits to colorful objects around the cabin. A few words slipped out under my breath, half-thought, half-sound. Then I did the same to the right. It probably looked insane, but in my head I was lining up numbers with colors, the way I always do. My own strange little brain map of light, color, and logic.
Some people claim numbers don’t have colors, which has always seemed deeply suspicious to me. How do you think of a number without giving it color and texture? My brain assigned each digit its own shade when I was little, and now the system works whether I ask it to or not.
I tilted my head, studying him. “You do realize we’ve officially crossed from coincidence into intent, right? This isn’t random, it’s practically annotated.”
Zan didn’t answer, but I knew we were on the same page. He just didn’t want to admit it.
He stared at the parchment a moment longer before folding it with quiet precision, the edges aligning perfectly beneath his fingertips. When he looked up, his expression had shifted, calm again.
“I’ll check it out,” he said, his tone even, almost gentle. “But I’ll go alone.”
He slipped the folded parchment into the inside breast pocket of his jacket. “You should get some rest,” he said quietly. “It’s been a long day. Let’s go, I’ll take you back to the house.”
I looked at him, loudly exhaled, and pulled my phone out of the back pocket. I should’ve just taken a photo of the parchment when I had the chance. So I glanced to my left, scanned it up, then down, translating the colors of the chosen objects back to numbers, thumb hovering over the screen as I typed. Then I shifted to the right, did the same up, down, another few taps.
I met his eyes for a moment that lingered just a second too long, and said, “Okay.” Then slipped the phone back into my pocket, the motion calm, almost casual. He studied me, but I gave him no resistance, no reaction. Just stillness.
The way back was quiet. The hum of the motor filled the gaps where conversation should’ve been, and neither of us bothered to fight it. Zan kept his attention on the water while I watched the shoreline, trying to sort through everything that had happened since I’d woken him over the foxes. There was plenty to think about, including his decision to continue without me, but my mind kept returning to the closet.
I could still remember the warmth of his hand through my clothes. Under ordinary circumstances, being shut in a small space with a man holding me against him would have brought an immediate, almost violent urge to push him away. I wasn’t particularly comfortable being touched, even by men I’d chosen to be close to. With Zan, that uneasiness hadn’t surfaced. I’d felt at ease in his arms and surprised by how much I enjoyed being held.
That was the part I couldn’t account for. I wasn’t nervous around him, didn’t rehearse things before saying them or spend hours afterward wondering how they’d sounded. Mostly, I enjoyed his company, except when he was being infuriating, which admittedly occupied a fair portion of it. He was Betty’s son, someone I was getting to know and beginning to think of as a friend. I hadn’t given much thought to anything beyond that.
Then he’d put his hand on my waist, and apparently there was something beyond that.
I looked over at him. He was watching the water ahead, one hand on the throttle, seemingly quite occupied with getting us home. I wondered whether he’d noticed anything, then decided I would prefer to remain ignorant on that particular subject. Perhaps I’d developed an inconvenient taste for danger. Although, considering how readily I’d have stayed in that closet after the danger had passed, that explanation needed work.
By the time we reached the dock, the air had cooled, heavy with that damp, briny stillness that settles over the island at dusk.
Before he could kill the engine, I stepped closer to the helm. “Hey,” I said evenly, “my phone’s got zero reception out here, and I just want to see how far this actually is. Mind if I check something real quick?”
He didn’t answer. Just looked at me.
So I turned to the navigation screen, typed the coordinate sequence from my phone into the GPS, and watched the tiny crosshair flicker to life.
The dot blinked just offshore.
“It’s… on the water,” I said quietly, tapping the screen.
“Can we compare notes?” I said, my tone light, though every word carried an edge. “If I’m off by even one digit, I’ll have to circle a larger area. I’d rather not make a scene tomorrow asking the locals for help. From what I’ve gathered, you’re not big on attention.” I gave him a small, pointed smile. “So really, out of respect, I’m doing you a favor.”
He finally reached into his jacket, pulled the parchment from his pocket, and unfolded it beside the GPS. His eyes moved from the faded ink to the numbers on the screen, comparing them one by one.
“Did I get them right?”
He folded the paper again, slid it back into his pocket, and looked at me with a flicker of disbelief and annoyance, buried under restraint.
“Listen,” I started, leaning a little closer. “I know what I look like from your side. I’m an outsider. I showed up out of nowhere, moved into Betty’s house, started peeling back your past, and somehow made myself impossible to ignore. I’m a loose end and an inconvenience.”
He didn’t move.
“But here’s the thing,” I continued. “I didn’t ask for any of this. I didn’t come here to chase mysteries or reopen someone else’s old wounds. I came here to get away from everyone. To breathe. Maybe conduct a few Soviet-French culinary experiments. That’s it.”
I paused, then pointed between us. “Yet somehow, you and I, in one day, managed to find two things Harrington deliberately hid. And maybe we’ll find more at these coordinates. On your own, you couldn’t find these things in seventeen years.”
He kept looking at me without saying a word.
“I’m not here to complicate your life,” I went on, softer now. “But I do care about Betty, and I’m wired for meaning and truth in ways I can’t switch off. Walking away isn’t something I’m capable of.”
I tilted my head, watching him. “You want to stay in control? Great. You can. Supervise me, babysit me, keep me on a short leash, whatever makes you comfortable. You and I both know you’ll have more control if I’m with you rather than if I’m out there tomorrow renting a boat and drawing attention to myself.”
I let the silence hang for a beat, then added, “Maybe Harrington himself sent me to you from his grave to finish the job properly this time.”
He still hadn’t told me whether I’d remembered the numbers correctly.
Begging is not in my vocabulary. Fighting him would have complicated the evening. This left exactly one move I didn’t like but had to execute. Was it morally questionable? Yes. Unfortunately, so was excluding me from a mystery I had helped drag out of the windows.
I took a deep breath and stepped closer, erasing the distance between us until the space between our faces felt negotiable. Without breaking eye contact, I placed my hand flat against his chest, steady and deliberate, right above his heart. His eyes flickered. A brief, unmistakable misread. I stayed still, letting him draw the wrong conclusion, then slowly slid my hand downward, hoping my confidence looked more convincing than it felt. His breath hitched, barely. It was just enough to suggest the distraction was working. My fingers slipped inside his jacket and came back out with the parchment. Jeez, it worked, I thought, mildly alarmed by this newly discovered skill of mine.
Yes, it was a terrible move. Effective, though, which is how most terrible moves defend themselves.
“I didn’t consent to being excluded,” I said, my tone soft but firm, “so can we just skip the noble you resisting me resisting you and go see what’s there?”
Write a comment