Enem’s medieval Christianity questions trigger annulment fight
Enem’s medieval Christianity questions trigger annulment fight
Questions on medieval Christianity in Brazil’s 2026 Enem university entrance exam have drawn demands for an investigation and annulment from lawmakers, religious leaders and advocates, while the exam’s administrator, Inep, has defended its review process and the historical framing of the items.
The main dispute concerns question 62 in the blue test booklet, which used historian Jean Delumeau’s account of 13th-century religious sermons as vehicles for “misogyny with a theological basis.” A second item, question 78, addressed social hierarchy in medieval monasteries. The Brazilian Institute of Law and Religion (IBDR) argues that the questions imposed a narrow reading of Christianity and monastic life. Rafael Durand Couto, a religious-law specialist representing the group, said candidates were required to accept a premise that “misrepresents their own faith” or risk losing points, calling it an “ideological toll.”
Senator Magno Malta has asked federal prosecutors to examine the exam’s preparation and validation procedures and called for question 62 to be voided. He said its inclusion showed a “failure of pedagogical and institutional judgment,” while framing annulment as a way to protect the exam’s credibility and prevent historical narratives used to justify discrimination from receiving institutional validation.
The critics’ argument is not that troubling attitudes toward women never appeared in religious history. Father and historian Jorge Ricardo Lindner said some early preachers used arguments portraying women as inclined toward evil, sometimes as rhetoric and sometimes from conviction. But he stressed that each sermon must be read in its own historical context. He also pointed to the Benedictine tradition’s role in raising the status of manual work, contrasting it with older societies that often associated physical labor with enslaved or lower-status groups.
Inep takes the opposing view that historical analysis does not amount to official endorsement. It says Enem questions undergo technical and pedagogical drafting, review and validation by teachers and specialists, and maintains that there is no basis to annul the contested item.
https://brazil-test-hub.syndichain.com Brazil News Hub brazil-test-hub brazil-test-hub
Write a comment