Ventilator case indicts 17, but leaves Rui Costa outside the charges

Brazil’s Federal Police indicted 17 people over an undelivered R$48.7 million ventilator purchase, while finding insufficient evidence to charge former Bahia governor Rui Costa or Aline Peixoto. Coverage differs over whether the focus is the alleged scheme or the evidentiary gaps.
Ventilator case indicts 17, but leaves Rui Costa outside the charges

Ventilator case indicts 17, but leaves Rui Costa outside the charges
Brazil’s Federal Police has concluded its investigation into the Nordeste Consortium’s 2020 purchase of 300 ventilators, indicting 17 people after the equipment was never delivered despite an advance payment of R$48.7 million. Former Bahia governor Rui Costa, who chaired the consortium at the time, and his wife, Aline Peixoto, were investigated but were not indicted.

The two accounts present the same outcome through different lenses. The Brazil Right account centers on the absence of direct proof against Costa and Peixoto. It says investigators could not establish whether intermediary Cleber Isaac genuinely communicated with the couple or merely invoked their names to project influence. It also notes that police found indications of more frequent contact between Costa and Isaac than Costa had described, but concluded the evidence did not support an indictment.

That account further emphasizes investigative shortcomings: key phones were reportedly handed over without data, and the initial state-level handling of a matter involving federal funds may have limited the collection of evidence. Costa’s office said the findings reinforced his defense and that he expected those responsible for the lost funds to be punished.

The Brazil Left account, while likewise stressing that police lacked evidence to attribute criminal participation to Costa and Peixoto, concentrates on the alleged conduct of those charged. It identifies former Bahia officials, consortium staff, business figures and intermediaries among the 17, with suspected offenses including procurement fraud, document falsification, money laundering and corruption. Police alleged that the supplier was selected without adequate checks and received payment in advance despite lacking demonstrated capacity to provide the ventilators.

It also reports that police examined messages and plea-bargain statements linking Costa’s name to the negotiations, but found no first-hand records sufficient to prove his involvement. The Federal Public Prosecutor’s Office will decide whether the evidence warrants criminal charges in court.

https://brazil-test-hub.syndichain.com Brazil News Hub brazil-test-hub brazil-test-hub

Write a comment