Court Orders NYC to Give Names of Shelter Residents to ICE

A facts-only brief, written by a local AI model from this article in The Wall Street Journal, November 9, 2026. It may contain mistakes, and it is not the article: the full story is at wsj.com.

U.S. District Judge Lewis Kaplan ordered New York City to provide Immigration and Customs Enforcement with the names and birth dates of male residents in a Bronx homeless shelter. The court-appointed special master will review these records and release only the identities of individuals with serious criminal histories, such as murder or rape, to the agency. Kaplan determined that the city failed to demonstrate that complying with the August 2025 subpoena was unduly burdensome or issued in bad faith. The judge concluded that the requested information is material to federal immigration law enforcement.

Background

• The Mamdani administration opposed the subpoena, characterizing it as a fishing expedition that conflicts with the city’s sanctuary laws.
• In October, a federal judge upheld New York City’s sanctuary statutes, rejecting a Trump administration lawsuit aimed at forcing local police to transfer detained migrants to federal custody.
• Local and federal Democratic lawmakers previously urged private parking operators to deny ICE access to their facilities after agents used a lot during an operation involving the shooting of Oscar Belgal.

Read the full article at wsj.com

More from Monday, November 9: