Karmelo Anthony defense, prosecutors wage first-impression war as emotions rock opening of trial: expert The first day of Karmelo Anthony’s murder trial featured a 911 call, surveillance footage, and emotional testimony from those who attempted to save stabbing victim Austin Metcalf. Prosecutors called the stabbing an “unprovoked unjustified murder,” while the defense argued Anthony acted in “a split second of fear and chaos” in self-defense. Key evidence includes surveillance footage and witness accounts of the confrontation and its immediate aftermath.

• Karmelo Anthony is on trial for the murder of Austin Metcalf, who was fatally stabbed at a high school track meet in April 2025.
• Anthony has pleaded not guilty, claiming self-defense.
• Jurors heard a 911 call detailing CPR efforts and saw surveillance footage from the event.
• Witnesses included coaches and trainers who tried to save Metcalf’s life.
• The defense must prove the self-defense claim, according to legal analyst Jeremy Rosenthal.
• Tensions were high outside the courthouse, with supporters of both Metcalf and Anthony engaging in a shouting match.
• Prosecutors described the incident as “provoked unjustified murder,” while the defense emphasized “fear and chaos.”
• The 911 call captured Metcalf’s struggles and the efforts to revive him.
• Witnesses described seeing the stabbing and attempting to render aid.