LSU alum Ben McDonald says he doesn't agree with NFL-to-college returns, but understands why coaches want them

The college football world is grappling with a trend of former NFL rookies returning to play in college, often seeking a fifth year of eligibility and the financial benefits of NIL. While some, like former LSU pitcher Ben McDonald, express disapproval of this practice, they understand the appeal for players and the strategic advantage it offers coaches like Lane Kiffin. Court proceedings and injunctions are adding complexity to the NCAA’s pushback against these guidelines, impacting incoming freshman classes.

• A growing trend of former NFL players returning to college for an additional year of eligibility and NIL money is causing controversy.
• Former LSU star Ben McDonald opposes the trend but understands why coaches want experienced players.
• NFL agents highlight that college pay can exceed NFL practice squad salaries for developing players.
• Coaches like Lane Kiffin see the competitive advantage in acquiring players with NFL training camp experience.
• Concerns exist that these returns may limit opportunities for incoming freshman classes.
• Legal battles are underway concerning the NCAA’s stance on these player movements.