Google Business Profile Setup: Only 3 of 13 ChatGPT Ratings Matched Google

We asked Google AI Mode and ChatGPT 12 local questions and traced where each listing's details came from. The two engines didn't agree.
Google Business Profile Setup: Only 3 of 13 ChatGPT Ratings Matched Google

We asked Google AI Mode and ChatGPT 12 local questions and traced where each listing’s details came from. The two engines didn’t agree.

Data from Search Shift’s own test: 12 local questions, once each, across 12 US cities, all on October 19, 2026.

Panel titled AI Local Answers, By the Numbers: AI Mode listings: 10 of 12 answers; AI Mode place cards: 47; ChatGPT business cards: 43 in 9 of 12 answers; ChatGPT ratings matching Google: 3 of 13; Tagged website links in ChatGPT: 6 of 43; Yelp cited by ChatGPT: 4 of 12 answers

Numbers in the post

Number What the post says Source Data from
12 We asked 12 local questions once each, across 12 US cities, all on October 19, 2026. They were the kind a customer types: “best plumber in Austin TX,” “dog groomer in Seattle,” “bakery in Boston.” Search Shift test October 19, 2026
10 of 12 (47) In our October 19 test, Google AI Mode put business listings in 10 of the 12 answers. That was 47 place cards in all. The cards showed the photos businesses had uploaded, Google’s rating and review count, whether the place was open, and the same three buttons you see in Maps: call, directions and website. Search Shift test October 19, 2026
9 of 12 (43) ChatGPT showed business cards in 9 of the 12 answers, 43 cards in all. Each had a name, category, address, phone number, rating and review count. Search Shift test October 19, 2026
3 of 13 For the 13 businesses that showed up in both engines, ChatGPT’s rating and review count matched Google’s for just 3. Search Shift test October 19, 2026
6 of 43 Six of the 43 website links carried tracking tags like “utm_source=gmb.” Businesses usually add those only to the website field of their Google profile. Search Shift test October 19, 2026
4 of 12 ChatGPT cited Yelp in 4 of the 12 answers. Search Shift test October 19, 2026
3.9 vs 4.4 Pequod’s Pizza in Chicago got 3.9 stars from about 9,000 reviews in ChatGPT. In Google AI Mode it got 4.4 stars from about 17,000. Same pizzeria, same day: October 19, 2026. Search Shift test October 19, 2026

Write a comment